The Amazon/Macmillan Debacle

- Image via CrunchBase
It looks like Amazon has realized it’s mistake and reached an agreement with Macmillan over the prices of e-books for the Kindle, but the entire issue (and the strong-arm tactics Amazon chose to employ against Macmillan) only served to make me even more happy that I chose a nook.
You see, Macmillan wanted to charge a more dynamic range of prices (from about $6 to about $15) for its e-books, while releasing them at the same time as the hardcovers are released. Since a hardcover is typically priced at somewhere around $30, even the $15 e-book would be a bargain, but Amazon was insistent that all books for the Kindle be priced at $9.99 or below.
They call this “standing up for the consumer”, however they proved, with the de-listing of all Macmillan books, with the removal of purchased items from kindles, with DRM and ridiculously restrictive licensing, that the consumer is the last thing on their mind.
Because, you see, Macmillan was standing up for the people who produce those books, and Macmillan is one of the largest publishers of science fiction and fantasy literature in the country. When Amazon decided to de-list Macmillan entirely, they decided to wage war not just against a publishing giant, but against an entire genre, its fans, and the writers who write in that genre.
I’m glad that Macmillan held to its principles, here – if they are expected to offer e-books at paperback prices, it is perfectly reasonable to delay the e-book until the paperback release date, otherwise, it should be priced higher to ensure just compensation for the authors, editors, and other folks who work to produce that book. $15 is still a bargain to get a book on its hardcover release date, though if I want a book that badly, I’m likely to buy the hardcover anyway.
For my part, I’m so disgusted with Amazon’s approach to selling e-books that I’ve systematically changed all book links on this blog to Barnes and Noble. Because you see, as a writer, I expect to receive appropriate compensation for my work, and as a fan, I want to ensure that the people who produce the fiction I love don’t get shafted either.
On another, happier note, I’d like to encourage everyone to go visit the newly arrived blog of a friend of mine, Labyrinthine Library. He’s a designer, a dad, a geek, all that lovely stuff, and can be expected to have some interesting commentary on art, as well as life, the universe, and everything.
Related articles by Zemanta
- Together, lets break the Amazon monopoly on Kindles! (tobiasbuckell.com)
- Amazon Blinked (randomreality.blogware.com)
- Amazon concedes defeat in ebook row with Macmillan (guardian.co.uk)










Recent Comments