If you follow my Twitter, you know that I’ve been giving ecstatic recommendations for Scrivener lately, which is by far the best piece of writing software I’ve come across. But I realize that what works for me won’t necessarily work for everyone else, and as I’ve tried just about everything available, I thought I’d give a quick comparison.
yWriter – Free, Open Source – Windows/Linux

yWriter 5 Main Window
yWriter is typically seen as the “Free Alternative” to Scrivener, and I have used it extensively. It is excellent as an organizational tool, but the interface is inelegant and somewhat complicated to deal with, and can be a distraction from the writing. With yWriter, I found that it worked better for me to do my actual writing in a separate text editor, like Q10 or FocusWriter, and then import the finished document into yWriter for organization and editing. It does not have a true full-screen editor, and jumping between scenes is a little more obtrusive.
However, if you cannot afford Scrivener and are looking for a free option, yWriter is a great alternative, especially paired with a separate full-screen text editor. The import feature in yWriter is simple to use, you just have to use a standardized separator (Three asterisks: * * * ) between your scenes for it to recognize and separate them in the organizer. I used it for a long time with a lot of success, and while I sing odes to the joy of writing with Scrivener, I can’t deny that yWriter works well, even if only as an editing program.
I do still use another program created by the same programmer, Sonar 3, to track my manuscript submissions. It is a wonderful little program, and I’d recommend it wholeheartedly to everyone, especially if you have multiple manuscripts “in play” – in the submissions process – at once.
Liquid Story Binder – $45.95 US (30 day free trial) – Windows

Liquid Story Binder XE
LBS is beautiful, and the user interface is absolutely wonderful to look at and play with. And therein lies the problem. There is a point where a piece of software might just have too many features, and those features actually work to impede rather than assist your writing productivity. While I am sure anyone writing a particularly research-intensive project, comics writers, screenwriters who draw storyboards, and the like would find this program absolutely wonderful, I found that I spent all of my time fiddling around with the “features” and not actually getting any writing done. The program was more fun to play with than it was useful, at least for me.
Scrivener – $45.00 US – Mac OS (Windows and Linux versions currently in Beta)
Where LBS was overwhelming with too many features, and yWriter’s interface makes it difficult to work with, Scrivener is perfect in its simplicity. It has all of the organizational and outlining features you could need without any unnecessary bloat, and the interface is unobtrusive and easy to work with. It is everything you need without being too much, and for me, the perpetually distracted, it has been an absolute lifesaver. I get more work done with Scrivener than I have ever been able to accomplish before. Where other programs seemed to hinder my productivity, Scrivener increased it.
While I love Scrivener for its simplicity, it still has plenty of features for those who want them. The difference is that all of the features are actually useful through every phase of the writing process without turning into time-wasting procrastination apps. And when you don’t need those features, they’re not screaming for you to go play with them. You can hide everything behind a full-screen editor. You can make the world go away and let it just be you and your text. Scrivener helps you get the thing done. For that, it has my everlasting affection.
Recent Comments